UK Independent. Sourced. Primary. · Est. 2024
Insurer data

1st Central insurance: complaints and claims data

First Central Insurance Management Limited received 9,305 complaints in January 2026 to June 2026 and upheld 39.3% of those it closed, according to FCA firm-level complaints data. For car insurance in 2025, 95 to 100% of claims were accepted and the average payout was in the £3500 to 4000 range, according to FCA value measures data.

1st Central policies are arranged by First Central Insurance Management Limited. The figures below are published by the Financial Conduct Authority for each legal entity, not for the brand as a whole.

Complaints

FirmPeriodComplaints openedClosed within 3 daysUpheld
First Central Insurance Management LimitedJanuary 2026 to June 20269,30559.1%39.3%

Claims by type of policy

Policy (2025)Claims frequencyClaims acceptedAverage payoutComplaints per claim
Car insurance10 to 15%95 to 100%£3500 to 40000 to 5%
Home insurance (buildings and contents)0 to 5%80 to 85%£4000 to 450010 to 15%

How to read this data

The FCA publishes claims figures for each firm in ranges, such as 90 to 95% of claims accepted, rather than exact numbers. Claims frequency is the share of policies that led to a claim; a higher acceptance rate means fewer claims were declined. Complaints figures count complaints the firm received about all its products, and the upheld rate is the share the firm itself found in the customer's favour. Neither measure is a price or a quality rating, and both depend on the mix of customers and policies.

Other insurers

Advertisement

Frequently asked questions

1

How many complaints does 1st Central get?

9,305 complaints in January 2026 to June 2026, with 39.3% upheld, from FCA data.

2

Does 1st Central pay out on claims?

95 to 100% of car insurance claims were accepted in 2025, according to the FCA.

3

Who underwrites the policies?

1st Central policies are arranged by First Central Insurance Management Limited.

4

What if my claim is turned down?

Complain to the insurer first. If it does not resolve the complaint within eight weeks, or you disagree with its final response, you can take it to the Financial Ombudsman Service for free.

5

Where does this data come from?

FCA general insurance value measures data 2025 and FCA firm-level complaints data, 2026 H1, both published by the FCA.

FCA data checked on 19 November 2026.

Sources

  1. FCA: General insurance value measures data 2025
  2. FCA: Firm-level complaints data

Figures on this page come from the official sources above. Kael Tripton UK Tools is independent and is not linked to any government body.

More UK tools

Kael Tripton UK ToolsFree calculators and official data. Read our UK guides