UK Independent. Sourced. Primary. · Est. 2024
Insurance claims data

Excess protection on car insurance (stand-alone): claims data

Insurers accepted 97.0% of excess protection on car insurance (stand-alone) claims in 2025, down from 97.5% in 2024, according to FCA value measures data. 444,614 policies were in force, and the average claim payout was £503.

Claims accepted 202597.0%Rank 4 of 34 products
Claims per policy7.8%
Average payout£503

Market figures 2024 and 2025

Measure20242025
Claims frequency (claims per policy)5.0%7.8%
Claims accepted97.5%97.0%
Average claim payout£445£503
Claim complaints as a share of claims0.81%0.90%
Policies in force (average)631,742444,614
Written premiums£48.3m£47.8m
Premiums per policy in force£76£107
Share of premiums paid out in claims28.7%34.0%

What the figures mean

Claims frequency is the number of claims made as a share of policies, so 7.8% means about 78 claims for every 1,000 policies. The acceptance rate is the share of those claims that insurers paid in full or in part. A low complaint rate means few claimants complained about how their claim was handled. Premiums per policy is total written premium divided by the average number of policies in force, which is a market average and not a quote. Insurers paid out 34.0% of premiums in claims in 2025; the rest covers running costs, commission and profit.

The FCA collects these figures from every firm with at least 3,000 policies and £400,000 of premiums for the product, and publishes them so buyers can see how products perform at claim time. For what to look for in a policy, see our kael tripton insurance hub.

Insurers' published bands

The FCA publishes each firm's figures in bands. The table lists the 5 firms that reported excess protection on car insurance (stand-alone) for 2025, in alphabetical order.

FirmClaims frequencyClaims acceptedAverage payoutComplaints per claim
AMERICAN INTERNATIONAL GROUP UK LIMITED5 - 10%95 - 100%£0 - 5000 - 5%
Atlas Insurance PCC Limited10 - 15%95 - 100%£500 - 10000 - 5%
Fortegra Europe Insurance Company Ltd10 - 15%95 - 100%£0 - 5000 - 5%
Newline Insurance Company Limited0 - 5%95 - 100%£0 - 5000 - 5%
Zurich Insurance Company Ltd10 - 15%95 - 100%£500 - 10000 - 5%
Advertisement

Frequently asked questions

1

What share of excess protection on car insurance (stand-alone) claims are accepted?

97.0% in 2025, from FCA data.

2

How often do people claim on excess protection on car insurance (stand-alone)?

Claims frequency was 7.8% in 2025.

3

How much does excess protection on car insurance (stand-alone) cost on average?

Written premiums divided by policies in force came to about £107 per policy in 2025. Individual prices vary.

4

Where does this data come from?

FCA general insurance value measures data 2025, covering 1 January to 31 December 2025.

5

Does a high acceptance rate mean a policy is better?

Not on its own. Check what the policy covers, the excess and the limits, as a policy with narrow cover can still have a high acceptance rate.

FCA data locked on 5 May 2026, covering 1 January to 31 December 2025. Checked on 16 November 2026.

Sources

  1. FCA: General insurance value measures data 2025

Figures on this page come from the official sources above. Kael Tripton UK Tools is independent and is not linked to any government body.

More UK tools

Kael Tripton UK ToolsFree calculators and official data. Read our UK guides